Skip to content

THE AMHERST CURRENT

  • About us
  • Comment policy
  • Contributors
  • Contact
  • Councilors’ statements on the Jones Library project
  • Fact check
  • On our radar
  • Recent House Sales
  • Town Government 101
    • Your Town government
    • Overview of Town departments
    • Overview of the Four Major Capital Projects and the Financing Plan
    • Elementary school building project
    • Jones Library expansion & renovation
    • Department of Public Works facility
    • Fire Station
  • All Posts
    • Let’s separate fact from fiction
    • Only-in-Amherst stories as two newspapers merge, 1988-2003
    • The Orchard Arboretum: a little-known Amherst gem
    • Never forgotten
    • A brief history of Amherst journalism, Part One: 1977-89
    • When will my road be paved? And why is a bear on my deck?
    • Four more renowned writers who once lived in Amherst
    • Welcome, Spring!
    • Envisioning Amherst as a model of rural economic revival
    • Emily Dickinson and Mabel Loomis Todd lived nearby but their lifestyles were far apart
    • Opportunities and challenges at the two elementary school building sites becoming clearer
    • Game on! The Amherst Invitational Ultimate tournament returns
    • We need neighborhood policy; Why I like Orchard Valley
    • Elementary school building project: Community forum on May 5
    • Live-music site opens this week
    • UMass Amherst announces plan to be carbon-neutral by 2032
    • New voting map leaves District 3 with no incumbent Councilors
    • Community responder director has already had ‘huge impact’
    • Reparations group plans to document racial injustice
    • Student housing and behavior: assessing problems and solutions
    • Aging and dementia: Looking at Amherst through a different lens
    • Amherst’s new live performance venue, the Drake, opens April 28
    • Net-zero energy schools are old news in Kentucky
    • ‘Tis the season — for potholes
    • Remembering Baer Tierkel
    • What’s up with . . . ?
    • Houses of five famous writers visible on brief walking tour
    • What is a good downtown plan?
    • Public money for private property owners? Yes!
    • A civil conversation, Part 3
    • Town lifts mask mandate
    • Amherst should get more money from UMass and the colleges
    • A civil conversation, Part 2
    • Designing for education
    • Let’s declare a moratorium on moratoriums
    • Rental bylaw, garage decisions on Town Council’s to-do list
    • Town-wide solar assessment should precede solar zoning bylaw
    • Ski town?
    • Community responder program presents some challenges
    • Too big? Too expensive? Don’t panic!
    • Supporting and retaining Amherst school leaders
    • A civil conversation, part 1
    • The next two years, part 1
    • Two announcements
    • Amherst elementary school building project: update
    • The Big Money: 2021 wraps up
    • Two views on solar moratorium
    • Parking permit fee increases proposed to Town Council
    • Why is my tax bill so high?
    • The case for local reparations
    • Local farmer makes a world of difference
    • Judge decides in Town’s favor on Jones Library lawsuits
    • Public welcome to attend educational visioning workshops to assist school building effort
    • Solar on landfills and parking lots
    • A look backward and a look forward: Evan Ross
    • A look backward and a look forward: George Ryan and Stephen Schreiber
    • A look backward and a look forward: Alisa Brewer
    • ‘Twas the week before Christmas
    • Bigger pie, or smaller appetite?
    • “I do not like that man. I must get to know him better”
    • An update from the School Committee and Building Committee chairs
    • CVS option for a parking garage should not be ruled out
    • New website for the elementary school building project is launched today
    • Thinking globally, acting locally: How to respond to climate crisis
    • Public comments on community responders sought Thursday
    • Silver lining, dark cloud
    • Vote on elementary school project is not likely before 2023
    • It’s crunch time on Town Council and tempers are flaring
    • Widening the circle
    • Town receives first installment of state library grant
    • Thanksgiving
    • D4 recount: Rooney beats Ross
    • Ah, the quiet…Argh, the noise!
    • Elementary school building projects kicks into higher gear
    • Please stop whining
    • Balance, not labels, needed in our debate over development
    • On our radar
    • Surrounded by beauty
    • Extra ballots: 14 “Yes,” 2 “No”
    • How do you want your local tax dollars spent?
    • The day after the day after
    • 21 political observers offer their views on Tuesday’s election
    • Jones Library vote 65.4% Yes; Walker, Hanneke, Steinberg win; Pam, Taub, Lopes, Rooney also elected; Page, Rhodes to join School Committee (unofficial results)
    • Today is the big day!
    • Our 20 one-sentence reasons to vote ‘Yes’ on Tuesday
    • Where is the Big Money? The campaign finance story, part 3
    • Amherst, on principle
    • Climate committee chair counters charges against councilors
    • The Amherst Business Improvement District corrects the record
    • Where is the Big Money? The campaign finance story, part 2
    • Where is the Big Money? The campaign money story, part 1
    • I went from skeptic to supporter on Jones Library project
    • Councilor defends 4 colleagues after recent attacks
    • Unopposed candidates speak up
    • Candidates for Amherst School Committee speak at a recent forum
    • Jones Library Trustees announce anti-racism policy for the Building Committee
    • Is Trump coming to Amherst?
    • Two energy experts endorse Jones Library renovation project
    • Ross, Lopes, Rooney articulate their positions in D4 forum
    • Amherst needs more senior housing
    • District 3 Candidate forum
    • Rumors on library plan refuted
    • Candidate forum: At-Large Councilors
    • Music and performance venue planned for downtown
    • Candidates air views at forum
    • Downtown businesses seek renaissance
    • Climate change: What is our town doing?
    • Fiscal sustainability: Some modest proposals
    • In their own words
    • Housing for all – can we thread the needle?
    • Political parties in Amherst
    • Moving Amherst’s 6th-graders is a good idea – and gets us a new school
    • Policing alternative: how it would work
    • Deciphering downtown parking
    • Can we afford four building projects? Yes! Here’s how
    • Students face housing squeeze
    • Want action on climate? On Nov. 2, vote “yes”
    • Vital to all, but getting no respect
    • Why Amherst needs the Jones Library project ASAP
    • Let’s densify!
    • A Historic Vote is Coming on a Long-overdue Elementary School
    • A Tale of Two PACs
    • So Many Budgets!
    • Preservation and Development Can Work Together
    • Power and loathing in Amherst
    • Amherst House Prices Shoot Up
    • Don’t Fence Me In
    • Reflections on the Charter: Ranked-choice voting
    • Reflections on the Charter: Participatory budgeting
    • Hello, Amherst!

Categories

  • Agriculture & open space
  • Amherst schools
  • Arts & entertainment
  • Business
  • Candidate panels
  • Civic engagement
  • Climate change mitigation
  • Development & Housing
  • DPW project
  • Editors' Notes
  • Elementary school building project
  • Housing
  • Jones Library
  • Local taxes
  • Natural world
  • Neighborhoods
  • Opinion
  • Public safety
  • Recreation
  • Social justice
  • Town finances
  • Town services
  • Uncategorized
  • Welcome
  • Zoning

Let’s separate fact from fiction

By Allison McDonald

When it comes to the elementary school building project in Amherst, by all means – advocate with elected and public decision makers. The project will be all the better with more voices and perspectives in the mix.

But, effective advocacy should not rely on misleading statements or false claims. This post is to fact-check a number of these statements and claims.

Image by chenspec from Pixabay

A petition is going around, created by a PAC in Amherst, that compares the two potential building sites, providing some accurate info but leaving out other critical information and including statements that are misleading or false. Specifically:

  • Yes, the project designers have recommended a roundabout be constructed at the Wildwood entrance to accommodate the increased traffic from the consolidated school. But they also recommended construction to widen the road in front of Fort River to accommodate the increased traffic at that site. And, importantly, the traffic study (completed by traffic engineers) demonstrates that the traffic around the Fort River site is significantly worse than around the Wildwood site, both today and after potential construction at either location.
  • No, Fort River will not “most likely be sold or leased for development” were Wildwood selected as the site for the consolidated school. There has been no such discussion. In fact, multiple Town Councilors have stated in public meetings their commitment to retaining both properties for the town.
  • No, it’s not true that the community fields at the Fort River location “would likely be lost.” Again, there has been no such discussion. If the Wildwood location were to be selected for the building project, improvements to fields at the Fort River location will not be part of the project but the fields will by no means “be lost.” In fact, since the latest estimates show that the building costs at the Wildwood location could be approximately $2 million lower than at Fort River, the community could use some of those savings to improve the community fields at Fort River should it choose.
  • Yes, the full project completion will take longer at the Wildwood location than at the Fort River location. But, students will move into the new building in fall of 2026 in either location. If the Wildwood location is selected, the rebuilding of a parking lot would need to be completed by the following spring or summer.
  • Yes, decisions eventually will need to be made about what to do with the site that is not selected for the school building project, and many interesting and worthy ideas have already been proposed. But, both Wildwood and Fort River buildings are failing – it’s why we are consolidating the two schools in this building project, after all. Repurposing either one of the buildings would cost millions in renovations and repairs – and in the case of Wildwood, removal of hazardous materials – that are not part of this school building project. And, any such decision can only be made after the decision is made about which location is best for the consolidated elementary school.

I, personally, am concerned about the extended period of limited access to outdoor spaces for students during construction were the Wildwood location selected, but the choice of building location is far from a “clear choice” or a “no-brainer” as some would have you believe.

The facts and professional analyses both demonstrate that while there are pros and cons associated with each location, both are workable. The Elementary School Building Committee has a tough decision to make when it meets on June 13, and I will support them whatever choice they make. Because the most important thing is that we get our students into a new school building as soon as possible.

Allison McDonald is the chair of the Amherst School Committee; the views expressed in this column are her own. (From the editors: Continue below for important alerts.)

The Elementary School Building Committee is hosting a Community Forum tomorrow night, Thursday, on Zoom, 6:30-9:00 p.m. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/86119993876 Meeting ID  861 1999 3876

The Elementary School Building Committee will meet next Monday morning, 8:30-11:00 a.m. by Zoom and may vote on the preferred option (that is, location and type of construction) at that time. Here is the link. Meeting ID 829 3205 2132

There will be no post tomorrow.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted on June 8, 2022June 8, 2022Author The Amherst CurrentCategories Amherst schools, Civic engagement, Elementary school building project

Post navigation

Previous Previous post: Only-in-Amherst stories as two newspapers merge, 1988-2003
Next Next post: From the editors
Blog at WordPress.com.
  • Follow Following
    • THE AMHERST CURRENT
    • Join 301 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • THE AMHERST CURRENT
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: